Article by Advocate Maya Gopal
The Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA), aims to increase transparency, accountability, and efficiency in the Indian real estate sector. It seeks to protect consumer interests and create a fair market for buyers and developers. Maharashtra's Real Estate Regulatory Authority (MAHA RERA), established in 2017, regulates real estate transactions in the state. It safeguards homebuyers' rights and provides a grievance redressal mechanism.
For senior citizens, the purchase of a home often represents a significant life investment, intended to provide security and stability in their later years. Delays in obtaining possession of their property can lead to considerable hardship, including financial strain, emotional distress, and uncertainty about their living arrangements. Given their potential vulnerabilities, it is particularly important for senior citizen homebuyers in Maharashtra to be well-informed about their rights and the protections available to them under MAHA RERA in cases where developers fail to deliver timely possession of their flats. This report aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the relevant provisions, procedures, and remedies available to senior citizens under MAHA RERA when faced with such delays.
Under MAHA RERA, developers are legally bound to deliver apartments to buyers by the possession date specified in the agreement for sale. This agreement is the core document defining the transaction, and MAHA RERA generally enforces its timelines.
If a developer fails to meet this deadline, Section 18 of the RERA Act offers crucial remedies for all buyers, including senior citizens. They can either:
Importantly, even though developers must declare a possession date when registering with MAHA RERA, the Supreme Court has ruled that the date in the agreement for sale takes priority. This prevents developers from using RERA registration to push back deadlines they initially agreed to. Finally, developers must provide MAHA RERA with a single, consistent possession date for all units in a project, ensuring transparency and equal treatment for all buyers, including senior citizens.
While MAHA RERA prioritizes senior citizen housing needs in terms of design and amenities, there are no specific, expedited procedures for them regarding delayed possession. However, senior citizens are fully protected by the general MAHA RERA provisions. They can:
The lack of specialized rules doesn't remove their rights as homebuyers under MAHA RERA. Although not legally required, it's possible MAHA RERA might handle senior citizen complaints with extra consideration due to their age and potential vulnerabilities, based on general principles of fairness.
Senior citizens in Maharashtra who are facing delayed possession of their flats have the right to file a complaint with MAHA RERA to seek redressal. The process for filing a complaint is primarily online, designed to be accessible and efficient. The steps involved in filing a complaint are as follows:
The first step is to visit the official MAHA RERA website (https://maharerait.mahaonline.gov.in/) and register as a complainant by clicking on the "New Registration" option. This requires providing basic details such as name, contact information, and email address.
Once the account is created and verified, the complainant needs to log in using their username and password.
After logging in, the complainant should locate the section for "Complaint Registration" or "Add New Complaint". They will need to fill out an online form providing detailed information about the project, the developer, and the specifics of their complaint regarding the delayed possession. This includes details such as the project registration number, the name of the developer, the building/wing/flat number, the total consideration value, the amount paid to date, the date of booking/allotment, the date of the agreement for sale (if any), and the promised date of possession as per the agreement. It is crucial to provide a clear and factual description of the issue, including relevant dates and reference numbers.
Along with the online form, the complainant will be required to upload scanned copies of essential documents that support their claim. These typically include the agreement for sale, receipts of payments made to the builder, any letters or email correspondence with the builder regarding the delay, the project brochure (if available), and the allotment letter.
MAHA RERA charges a nominal fee for filing complaints. This fee can be paid securely online through various payment options such as debit/credit cards or net banking.
After filing the complaint online, the complainant is required to submit a "convenience document set," which should not exceed 20 pages, as per MAHA RERA guidelines.
Once the complaint is filed online, the MAHA RERA registry will examine and scrutinize it to ensure it complies with the necessary requirements. If any objections are found, the registry will inform the complainant to rectify them. Upon removal of objections, the complaint will be assigned to the concerned bench of the authority.
The hearing of the complaint will be scheduled based on seniority. On the first date of hearing, if both parties agree to settle the matter amicably, the complaint may be referred to the conciliation forum. If no amicable settlement is reached, further hearings will be conducted on the merits of the case. Both parties will have the opportunity to file their respective replies, rejoinders, and written submissions.
Source: https://maharera.maharashtra.gov.in/complaint-filing-under-registered-project| Remedy | Applicable Section of RERA Act/Rules | Rate of Interest | Penalty Amount | Conditions/Triggers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interest for Delay | Section 18 | SBI MCLR + 2% | N/A | Failure to give possession as per the agreement for sale. |
| Refund with Interest | Section 18 | SBI MCLR + 2% | N/A | Failure to give possession as per the agreement for sale (if allottee wishes to withdraw). |
| Penalty for Non-compliance | Section 59, 63, 61 | N/A | Up to 10% of project cost; Up to 5% of project cost; Daily fines for agents. | Non-registration of project, failure to comply with MAHA RERA orders, other violations. |
Recent judgments and orders by MAHA RERA and the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (MREAT) highlight the authorities' active role in addressing the issue of delayed possession and protecting the interests of homebuyers. In several cases, developers have been directed to refund the entire amount paid by homebuyers, along with interest, and in some instances, also to reimburse expenses such as stamp duty, registration charges, and pre-EMI amounts due to significant delays in handing over possession. These rulings demonstrate the willingness of MAHA RERA and MREAT to ensure that homebuyers are not left bearing the financial burden of undue delays caused by developers.
MREAT has also consistently upheld the right of homebuyers to claim interest for delayed possession, even when MAHA RERA had initially granted developers extended grace periods beyond what was stipulated in the sale agreement. This stance reinforces the importance of the possession date agreed upon in the sale agreement and limits the developers' ability to unilaterally prolong the timelines. Such judgments are particularly relevant for senior citizens who rely on the initially promised possession date for their critical life planning.
However, there have also been instances where relief for delayed possession was denied by MREAT due to the absence of monetary consideration in the agreement for sale. This underscores the critical importance for allottees, including senior citizens, to ensure that their property purchase is properly documented with a clearly stated monetary consideration in the agreement to be eligible for remedies under Section 18 of the RERA Act.
In a notable case involving senior citizens, the Bombay High Court intervened when the execution of a MAHA RERA order was significantly delayed (almost eighteen months). The High Court directed MAHA RERA to expedite the decision on the execution application, recognizing that senior citizens should not be made to wait indefinitely for the enforcement of orders passed in their favour. This highlights that senior citizen have recourse to higher judicial authorities if there are unreasonable delays in the implementation of MAHA RERA's directives. While this particular case focused on the execution of an order rather than the initial judgment on delayed possession, it demonstrates the judiciary's awareness of the specific vulnerabilities of senior citizens in such matters.
MAHA RERA provides mechanisms for dispute resolution beyond the formal complaint filing and adjudication process. One such mechanism is the conciliation forum, established to facilitate amicable settlements between promoters and allottees. This forum offers a platform for both parties to engage in discussions and attempt to reach a mutually acceptable resolution with the assistance of independent and impartial conciliators.
The process for initiating conciliation involves registering on the conciliation forum application portal through the MAHA RERA website. Once logged in, the allottee can fill out a conciliation request form, which is then communicated to the promoter. If the promoter accepts the conciliation request, the allottee can proceed with the payment of the necessary fees, after which a conciliation bench is assigned based on the seniority of the conciliation number. If a settlement is reached, the parties are required to sign a conciliation agreement, which is then uploaded to close the request. This settlement agreement is final and legally binding on all parties involved. In the event of non-compliance with the terms of the settlement by either party, the other party retains the right to approach MAHA RERA for further action.
In addition to the conciliation forum, MAHA RERA operates through an adjudicating officer system for handling claims up to Rs. 1 crore, while the Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (MREAT) serves as the appellate body for claims exceeding this amount and for appeals against the orders of MAHA RERA.
The conciliation forum can be a particularly beneficial option for senior citizens seeking to resolve disputes regarding delayed possession as it offers a less adversarial and potentially faster route to a resolution compared to formal legal proceedings. This can be especially appealing to those who prefer a more informal and less stressful approach to settling disagreements. To further enhance the accessibility of this mechanism for senior citizens, MAHA RERA could consider providing additional support or a dedicated desk within the conciliation forum to address their specific concerns and needs.
MAHA RERA mandates that real estate developers maintain transparency and keep homebuyers informed about the progress of their projects. Developers are obligated to provide regular updates on the construction status to homebuyers who have already invested in the project. This includes uploading project details and progress reports on the MAHA RERA website on a quarterly basis. Furthermore, allottees have the fundamental right to know the stage-wise time schedule for the completion of the project, including provisions for essential amenities.
In cases where there is an anticipated delay in handing over possession, developers are also required to notify homebuyers in writing about the delay and the reasons for it. This proactive communication is crucial for all homebuyers, especially senior citizens, as it allows them to plan their lives and finances more effectively. The mandate for regular updates from developers through the MAHA RERA portal aims to ensure this necessary transparency. To further improve communication with senior citizen homebuyers, MAHA RERA could consider requiring developers to establish a specific communication channel or designate a dedicated point of contact to address their queries and concerns related to project progress and possession timelines.
The research material indicates that MAHA RERA has been proactive in issuing guidelines and regulations specifically concerning senior citizen housing projects. These guidelines primarily focus on ensuring that housing projects marketed towards senior citizens meet certain minimum standards regarding design, accessibility, safety features, and the provision of necessary amenities. For example, MAHA RERA has mandated features such as wheelchair-accessible lifts, wider doorways, grab rails in bathrooms, and emergency alarm systems in senior living communities. These regulations aim to protect elderly residents from misleading promotions and inadequate facilities.
While these guidelines are crucial for ensuring the suitability of housing projects for senior citizens, the provided snippets do not reveal any specific advisories or public notices issued by MAHA RERA that are solely focused on the rights of senior citizen homebuyers specifically concerning delayed possession. However, it is important to reiterate that the general guidelines and regulations of MAHA RERA pertaining to timely possession apply equally to all homebuyers, including senior citizens. Recent measures by MAHA RERA, such as making it mandatory for developers to include detailed parking specifications and the delivery dates of amenities in the agreement for sale, are aimed at enhancing transparency and preventing disputes, which indirectly benefit all homebuyers, including senior citizens.
In conclusion, MAHA RERA provides a robust framework for protecting the rights of homebuyers, including senior citizens, in cases of delayed possession of their flats. Senior citizens have the right to receive information about the project, to expect possession as per the terms of the agreement for sale, and to seek remedies such as interest for the period of delay or a refund with interest if they wish to withdraw from the project. The agreement for sale is the primary document that defines the possession timeline, and MAHA RERA generally upholds the dates mentioned therein.
"On recommendation by one of the directors and we appointed S&M Associates under retainership for our company. They are fast and dynamic in their approach. They have helped us deal with our national as well as internationl legal issues.”
"Having collaborated with S&M Associates PAN India, they are our legal experts in all strategic areas.”
"It is indeed a pleasure when the work is completed without any untoward incidents and S&M ASSOCIATES made sure that everything moved at a steady pace, this ensuring customer satisfaction. S&M ASSOCIATES team are highly efficient, subject matter experts and worked with great vigor during the entire project. We would gladly opt for S&M ASSOCIATES's services again in the future when the need would arise and would be happy to recommend them to anybody who has the requirements for IPR services.”
"S&M Associates have always helped us in all our legal issues such as framing HR policies and mediating Labour disputes. They are quick with their consultations and are available at all times.”
"S&M Associates team are commercial, practical, and pleasure to deal with. They provide us with top notch assistance and peace of mind that we are in good hands in what can be a complex and sometimes difficult jurisdiction.”
"As an entrepreneur I was looking for law firm that is commercial and creative, proactive and esponsive with an ability to find effective solutions that make sense. S&M Associates is all that and has been a key business partner for us”
“One of the best law firms that
helped us with registration of
our building under RERA.”
“Quick and meticulous approach
towards clients.”
“Having collaborated with S&M
Associates PAN India, they are
our legal experts in all
strategic areas.”
“Advocate Maya Gopal helped us
through a smooth and
unburdensome divorce
proceedings.”
"I will recommend S&M Associates
to all my peers. One of the best
Divorce Law Firms."
“Quick to help us with
registration of our society.
From Title search to clearance,
they were with us and solved all
our doubts with no hesitation.”
“As an NRI, I received prompt
and quick service from S&M
Associates even during this
pandemic through virtual meeting
via ZOOM, which enabled me to
feel that I am personally
involved in my case in India.”
“Helped me in my property
matter. Quick service and prompt
outcome.”
“Currently working with S&M
Associates Team for registration
and legal matters.”
“Professional. Efficient.
Personable. The team at S&M
Associates executed my
dissolution expeditiously and
fairly. Highly recommend their
services."
"Our lawyers S&M Associates are
outstanding. Calm, patient,
reasonable during the turmoil we
were going through. We would
definitely use the service of
S&M Associates again.”
S&M ASSOCIATES is a well-established law firm with significant national capacity through a network of associates giving us sizable influence in key financial centers PAN India.
We offer full range of corporate and commercial legal services, including but not limited to, a comprehensive consulting service, dispute resolution, litigation, non-litigation, arbitration, employment, finance, company restructuring, real estate, and estates.
© Copyright by S&M